More On Oriented Containers and 'Containees'
A few years ago, I wrote this doc: https://arxiv.org/abs/1802.10447
Elaborating on one of the questions introduced therein (to find least area isosceles triangle that contains a given triangle), Kiss, Pach and Somlai proved some serious results here:
https://arxiv.org/pdf/2001.09525.pdf
Here is a bunch of questions (which have algorithmic as well as classical aspects) in the same vein:
Given a polygon (especially, a triangle), to find/characterize the:
- least area (or least perimeter) centrally symmetric polygon that contains it.
- max area (or max perimeter) centrally symmetric polygon that is contained within it.
- the least area(least perimeter) axisymmetric polygon (a polygon with at least one direction of symmetry) that contains it.
- max area(max perimeter) axisymmetric polygon that is contained within it.
Note 1: The concept of 'contained region with max perimeter' (whether axisymmetric or full centrally symmetric) can have a definite answer only if we are constrained to search only for convex regions contained within the input region; even with that constraint, the answer might be degenerate.
Note 2: I am not sure if there is an O(n) algorithm to check if a given n-gon is axisymmetric. An O(n^2) algorithm is easy to show: one just needs to check 2*n candidate lines - the n angular bisectors and the n perpendicular bisctors of the sides; each line can be tested in O(n) time to decide whether it is an axis of symmetry. Note: A discussion on this particular question is here: https://mathoverflow.net/questions/387005/check-if-a-polygon-has-an-axis-of-symmetry
Guesses:
- At least for some triangles, the least area axisymmetric container appears to be non-convex. Iam not sure if these optimal axisymmetric containers of triangles can be got by deforming(trimming) smallest isosceles containers (or special isosceles triangle containers - definition of 'special' is given in the paper by Kiss, Pach and Somlai mentioned above) of triangles.
- For any convex region, the max area contained region (whether axisymmetric or rotationally symmetric) is probably convex.
Elaborating on one of the questions introduced therein (to find least area isosceles triangle that contains a given triangle), Kiss, Pach and Somlai proved some serious results here:
https://arxiv.org/pdf/2001.09525.pdf
Here is a bunch of questions (which have algorithmic as well as classical aspects) in the same vein:
Given a polygon (especially, a triangle), to find/characterize the:
- least area (or least perimeter) centrally symmetric polygon that contains it.
- max area (or max perimeter) centrally symmetric polygon that is contained within it.
- the least area(least perimeter) axisymmetric polygon (a polygon with at least one direction of symmetry) that contains it.
- max area(max perimeter) axisymmetric polygon that is contained within it.
Note 1: The concept of 'contained region with max perimeter' (whether axisymmetric or full centrally symmetric) can have a definite answer only if we are constrained to search only for convex regions contained within the input region; even with that constraint, the answer might be degenerate.
Note 2: I am not sure if there is an O(n) algorithm to check if a given n-gon is axisymmetric. An O(n^2) algorithm is easy to show: one just needs to check 2*n candidate lines - the n angular bisectors and the n perpendicular bisctors of the sides; each line can be tested in O(n) time to decide whether it is an axis of symmetry. Note: A discussion on this particular question is here: https://mathoverflow.net/questions/387005/check-if-a-polygon-has-an-axis-of-symmetry
Guesses:
- At least for some triangles, the least area axisymmetric container appears to be non-convex. Iam not sure if these optimal axisymmetric containers of triangles can be got by deforming(trimming) smallest isosceles containers (or special isosceles triangle containers - definition of 'special' is given in the paper by Kiss, Pach and Somlai mentioned above) of triangles.
- For any convex region, the max area contained region (whether axisymmetric or rotationally symmetric) is probably convex.
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home